Dispelling the Protein Myth

The myth that we do not need to watch our proteinone thing, the variable, however, since humans do
intake is deeply embedded in American traditions andnot live in a laboratory setting, results would be
has become one if the backbones in the Standarddifficult to compare. Nonetheless, these results
American Diet. The National Meat and Dairy Councilsbecame adopted as the Official Nutrition Doctrine of
are the most prevalent and therefore influentialthe United States. Since then, there has been more
resources of information on nutrition in the U.S. Thesethan 77 years of research suggesting otherwise, but
councils also have leaders that switch back and forthwe do not hear about any of this from our common
between the industry and regulation sides of the U.S.modalities of nutritional information do we?
food supply. Normally, it is not ideal that an industryThe leading scientific authorities say there is a direct
also be involved in the regulation and education ofcorrelation between diet and disease and that we
their product.need to cut out animal products, processed foods
Our health care is ranked #41 and yet it is the mostand sugary foods from our diet. This requires a
expensive of any other country. Our leading causescomplete revamping of the Standard American Diet.
of death are heart disease, followed by medical care,Harvard researchers investigating strict plant food
and then cancer. Both heart disease and cancer arediets say we cannot become protein deficient by
nutrition-related. So, our current state of health &eating a mixed vegetable diet. The conservative
diet confirm that the Standard American Diet &National Academy of Science says that athletes do
protein intake is not working for us.not need any more protein than non-athletes, they
With respect to protein, the National Dairy Councilneed more calories. Dr. McDougall, a leading medical
recommends we get 13-17% of our total caloriesauthority on nutrition has stated that Osteoporosis is
coming from protein. This is a curious number, sincea disease caused by many factors, but the most
T. Colin Campbell found in his 40 year study on dietimportant factor is an excess of protein in the diet,
and health that eating any more than 3-5% of ourwhere there is an inversely related relationship
calories from protein led to disease onset. It is alsobetween protein and calcium loss. A March 1983
curious that 13-17% of calories in the Standardarticle in the Journal of Clinical Nutrition reported in the
American diet is from protein. Their proteinlargest study of this kind ever conducted that "male
recommendation comes from a study conducted invegetarians had an average measurable bone loss of
1914 by Osborn and Mendel on rats where the3%, male meat-eaters had an average measurable
carnivorous animals grew faster on animal than plantbone loss of 7%, female vegetarians had an average
protein. However, rats and humans have completelymeasurable bone loss of 18%, and female
different digestive systems with rats being designedmeat-eaters had an average measurable bone loss of
for rapid digestion and expulsion of animal protein,35%." An article published in the Journal of the
while humans are designed for slow digestion andAmerican Medical Association entitled "Rapid
absorption of every last nutrient in plant foods. Also,Growth-Shorter Life" found that "animal-protein
no tests were ever conducted on humans to verifymeasurably shortened the life spans of a number of
the results applied also to humans. Lastly, in adifferent animals.
laboratory setting, everything is controlled except