Osteoporosis - Will a High Protein, Low Carb Diet Increase or Reduce Bone Density?

Ever since the 1970s, nutritionists have been arguingregardless of age, weight, smoking habits, calcium
over the role of protein in maintaining bone health.intake and even estrogen use.
Some claim a high-protein diet makes the bodyIn March 2002 an important study showed that the
excrete more calcium, which in turn could weakencombination of a high protein intake and calcium and
bones. Others assert just the opposite: That dietaryvitamin D supplements significantly slows bone loss in
protein is essential for maintaining strong bones.older adults. The double-blind study followed nearly
Who's right?350 sixty-five-year-old men and women over a
Recent research strongly suggests that the proteinthree-year period. All the participants ate their usual
proponents were right all along. The research showsdiet, but half were also randomly assigned to take a
that a diet high in protein not only keeps your bonessupplement containing vitamin D and 500 milligrams of
healthy; it can significantly slow down the bone losscalcium, while the others took a dummy pill.
that leads to osteoporosis.At the end of three years, the researchers found
What all the studies show is that the amount ofthat among the people taking the calcium and vitamin
calcium you excrete depends on more than just howD supplements, the ones who ate the most protein
much protein you eat.had the strongest bones and absorbed the most
The amounts of phosphorus and magnesium in yourcalcium.
diet, for instance, play a significant role. But evenCheese and other dairy foods are a great source of
more importantly, there's simply a lot of normalcalcium. Just one ounce of cheddar cheese, for
variation in the amount of calcium individuals absorbinstance, gives you 204 mg. of calcium. There is a lot
from their food-some people just absorb more thanof calcium in other low carb foods, including nuts and
others, for reasons researchers still don't understand.green leafy vegetables.
In fact, your ability to absorb calcium from your foodThe latest research at Tufts University indicates that
is probably more important to your bone health thanstrength training at any age can actually add bone,
the total amount of calcium you take in.not just slow its loss. The study looked at two
Results from the long-running Framinghamgroups of women aged 50 to 70 for a year. One
Osteoporosis Study, published in 2000, showed thatgroup exercised 5 minutes on a cycle, stretched for
eating a diet high in protein has a protective effect5 minutes and did resistance exercise on several
on your bones as you age.pieces of strength equipment.
Among the 615 elderly people in the study, the onesThe other group continued their "couch potato" life
who ate the most protein had the strongest bones,style. When bone density was compared at the end
while the ones who ate the least protein had theof the study the strength training group added 1%
weakest bones. And over the four-year studycompared to a loss of 2.5% by the sedentary group.
period, the people who ate the least protein lostAs a bonus the strength training will improve your
significantly more bone mass than the people whobalance, lower blood sugar and burn calories while you
ate the most protein. The connection held upare sleeping.