The Fluoride In Our Drinking Water Controversy

A brief examination of the controversy surroundingwater because it recognizes the potential health
the addition of fluoride to our drinking water. Forhazards of the consumption of too much fluoride.
over 30 years, the controversy has raged about theSeveral countries in Europe, such as Sweden, France
benefits or the hazards of human consumption ofand Ireland have gone even further and sought
fluoride. Despite numerous studies conducted by suchmedical advice from some very prestigious institutes
organizations as the World Health Organizationsuch as the Nobel Medical Institute that recommends
(WHO) we seem to be no closer to definitiveagainst fluoridation of drinking water and these
answers to the question of whether fluoride in ourcountries have stopped adding fluoride to their
drinking water really does prevent tooth decay or ifdrinking water.
it is, in fact, contributing to major health problems likeA Harvard Study of boys drinking fluoridated vs.
cancer and osteoporosis.unfluoridated water, released April 5, 2006 concluded
Fluoride occurs naturally in drinking water is somethat boys who drink water with levels of fluoride
areas of the world, including parts of the Unitedconsidered safe by federal (EPA) guidelines are five
Stated and Canada. Many cities and towns also addtimes more likely to have a rare bone cancer than
fluoride to the drinking water supply during waterboys who drink unfluoridated water.
treatment. The addition of fluoride to drinking waterDr. Hardy Limeback B.SC., Ph.D. in Biochemistry, D.D.S.,
began in the 1940's because it was believed thathead of the Department of Preventive Dentistry for
fluoride prevents tooth decay. Since that time, manythe University of Toronto, and president of the
studies have been conducted and there is evidenceCanadian Association for Dental Research states that
that fluoride does play a part in preventing tooth"Children under three should never use fluoridated
decay although it is believed that with the level oftoothpaste," he counseled. "Or drink fluoridated
dental hygiene practiced today in the developedwater. And baby formula must never be made up
world the addition of fluoride to the water supply isusing Toronto tap water. Never.
unnecessary. On a more sinister side, other studies"Even if we accept that the addition of fluoride at
have concluded the fluoride may cause some verythe EPA regulated levels, 1.4 and 2.4 parts per million
serious health problems. The following quotation is(ppm) is save and will not increase our risks of
taken from the United States Environmentaldeveloping bone or other rare cancers, we also need
Protection Agency (EPA) website.to consider the fact that many beverages we drink
"Many communities add fluoride to their drinkingalso contribute to the amount of fluoride we
water to promote dental health. Each communityconsume on a daily basis. In a study of fluoride levels
makes its own decision about whether or not to addin fruit juices, over 42% of the fruit juices tested
fluoride. EPA has set an enforceable drinking waterwere found to contain fluoride at over 1 ppm with
standard for fluoride of 4 mg/L (some people whosome juices, particularly grape juices, as high a 3.0
drink water containing fluoride in excess of this levelppm.
over many years could get bone disease,including painThere seems to be as many scientists advocating
and tenderness of the bones). EPA has also set afluoride as there are issuing warnings about it. In the
secondary fluoride standard of 2 mg/L to protectmeantime, we are left without clear answers about
against dental fluorosis. Dental fluorosis, in itsthis long standing controversy. For those concerned
moderate or severe forms, may result in a brownabout the potential health risks posed by fluoride
staining and/or pitting of the permanent teeth. Thisconsumption, or families with small children, home
problem occurs only in developing teeth, before theywater filters can be installed that are very economical
erupt from the gums. Children under nine should notand very effective at removing fluoride from drinking
drink water that has more than 2 mg/L of fluoride.water.
"The EPA regulates the level of fluoride in drinking